Chris: “Let’s pick a word you would rarely hear me say, like. . . Arkansas.”
Never that easy to classify, the movies of Martin McDonagh (In Bruges, Seven Psychopaths, Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri; The Banshees of Inisherin), and now Wild Horse Nine (2026) tend to mix many a genre and theme, this newest entry combining both black comedy and searing drama into a true dramedy, all of that fitting within an historical spy thriller shot on the almost never used Easter Island (only the second feature to ever do so).
Set in 1973 (during the final year of President Salvador Allende’s government) and following Santiago stationed CIA Officers Chris Carlisle (John Malkovich) and Lee Chesterfield (Sam Rockwell – Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri; Seven Psychopaths; Jojo Rabbit), like most of McDonagh’s stories, this revolves around a bickering friendship. Though the senior officer is now in many ways under the control of his junior, as Chris is quickly dying of cancer and slowly losing his memory. . . much to the chagrin of their boss MJ (Steve Buscemi – Rising Sun; The Death of Stalin), who fears the man will leak national security secrets from the last several decades while he also keeps yapping about writing his memoirs (kind of frowned upon in the CIA).
For in many ways, that is why this story takes place on Easter Island, as Chris very much wants to see the large headed stone structures before he dies. Featuring legendary banter between the cast, it is hard to truly know what is going on, for not only is Chris struggling with memory problems, but he is also a notorious liar, while Lee has his own numerous issues – including his wife, Marge (Parker Posey), who is a serial cheater, including one time with a clown. Touching on topics revolving around heaven, moths, death, dinosaurs having souls, guilt, atonement, redemption, morality, conspiracy (around the JFK assassination no less), their boss being a possible junkie, bombs, midgets playing basketball, an unorthodox analysis of how styles of cheese impact a country’s Populus, and so much more. . . a complication finds Chris having forgotten that he has told Lee that he wants to be offed if he utters the word Arkansas (which is where the opening quote comes into play).
Further complicating things, Chris’ blunt boldness and bizarre Chilean threats have ticked off two young left-wing women, Monica (Mariana di Girolamo) and Alicia (Ailín Salas), who are also visiting the island. Throw in the fact that Chris has not spoken to his brother Jim (a memorable cameo from Tom Waits – Seven Psychopaths; The Old Man & the Gun) for a decade since a potato throwing feud, and that someone is secretly following the senior officer around the island, and there are plenty of issues to rectify while Chris still has time to do so.
As tensions bubble up, Chris grows more paranoid about everything – including his friendship with Lee (in fact, he leaves a note in his pocket not to trust the man), Lee worries about his wife and kids as more frantically alarming calls come from MJ, and an ominous pallor grows the longer they explore the place. Will the friendship of Chris and Lee survive the tumultuous times? Who is truly out to get Chris on the island. . . could it be MJ, a hired hand, or someone else completely?
Once again weaving a most dynamically complex tale, key elements are bandied about like the aforementioned John F. Kennedy assassination and the rifle involved, a wild horse that seems to be the kindred spirit of Chris, political scheming revolving around the Chilean government, the fears of tainting the soul before death (hence Chris not wanting to commit suicide), telling the truth versus lies, now possibly preferring to visit Venice instead of Easter Island as Chris’ last trip, as well as so many more aspects that would need several viewings to interpret. And cleverly, instead of being a traditional spy movie focused on the task at hand, it is subverted by only focusing on the aftermath of a mission, a complex friendship, and how to deal with Chris’ memory issue dilemma.
Matched with mesmeric acting, the entire main cast shine, while it would be no surprise that some Oscar nominations could be coming – especially for Rockwell. Also combined with Carter Burwell’s majestic score, he integrates elements of western (also note some unique horse talk between the buddies revolving around making a western that simply follows a horse as its main character), Chilean and even some tunes (for the second time in somewhat recent memory, the rather poignant The Rolling Stones ‘Out of Time’ plays an integral part in a movie – the other, Once Upon a Time in… Hollywood).
Another masterful film from Martin McDonagh, Wild Horse Nine once again exemplifies why he is one of the best original screenwriters of his day. When paired with its perfect casting, the simple yet effective directorial style that keeps its focus on what matters most, while also providing a rich concoction of so many deep emotions, it really makes for a movie that must be seen. Lastly, it is worth noting that Lee carries around and often uses a Super 8 camera as a tourist – real Super 8 and 16mm footage was processed and scanned by Cinelab for those scenes to give it that authentic vibe. So, keep it reel by taking a trip to Easter Island (or maybe even Venice), just make sure that it’s not Arkansas.



